After reading "Hungry Minds: Tales from a Chelsea Soup Kitchen" by Ian Frazier, I at first did not know why we were assigned this article because it seemed to be about homeless people in New York City. Reading further, I quickly found that the author of the article, Ian Frazier, utilized these soup kitchens in New York City to get homeless people to participate in a Writers' Workshop. On this idea, he stated, "There are so many hungers out there; the soup kitchen deals, efficiently and satisfyingly, with the most basic kind. I consider it, in its own fashion, a work of art" (Frazier 1). Basically, he wanted to satisfy the desires of those who wished to express themselves artistically through writing.
Utilizing this outlet for others' expressions, his idea to encourage these tired and hungry homeless people to participate in a Writers' Workshop seemed like a very inspiring one. He wanted them to tell their story so that others could understand. The examples he gave of his Writers' Workshop participants proved to be interesting and funny at times. I especially enjoyed the story about "Jeff, who disappeared one year and returned the next saying that he had been travelling internationally as a player on a homeless men’s soccer team (a claim that turned out to be true)" (Frazier 2). The fact that Jeff's story turned out to be true made it even better! Frazier definitely worked with his participants to encourage and inspire them to write out their stories, and I feel that every teacher should follow his lead.
Another part of the article that I felt exemplified an excellent way of writing was in Frazier's talk with another homeless man who came into contact with the Workshop Approach previously. He stated, "'When he wrote something, he always had two things going on at a time. He told us, when you writin’, you got this surface thing, you understan’, goin’ on up here'—he moved his left hand in a circle with his fingers spread apart, as if rubbing a flat surface—'an’ then once you get that goin’ on, now you got to come under it'—he brought his right hand under his left, as if throwing an uppercut—'come under this thing here that’s goin’ on up here, you understan’. That was how John Cheever said you write'" (Frazier 2). John Cheever's description of how to write a powerful piece is absolutely true. The works of literature that are considered to be classics all have a plot on the surface, but when one delves deeper into the text, the true meaning of the story shines through. For this reason, I felt this part really touched me as a teacher and writer. Overall, I really enjoyed Ian Frazier's article about his Writers' Workshop because it inspired and intrigued me to do the same in my classroom and community!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

I felt the same way about reading this article at first. I think Frazier could have deleted a lot of the history about the church and cut straight to the point. I did love Frazier's example of the workshop...pretty interesting stuff.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed this article as well. I felt that it was inspirational and encouraging. I also liked how Frazier gave examples of some of the works that the participants of the writer's workshop created. It really added to the story he was telling. Overall, two thumbs up!
ReplyDeleteI also did not understand how this article related to our class at first, but I soon saw the similarities between this situation and some schools. I really enjoyed the article and took a lot away from it. It seemed crazy that these people in New York could be such great writers, but it goes to show that anyone could be.
ReplyDelete